Peikoff vs. Hsieh on Transgenderism

 

Thanks to conversations with a fellow follower of the blog (you know who you are! Haha), I was recently inspired to do a little bit of digging to see what the different modern Objectivist intellectuals had to say on this issue. I was surprised to discover such sharp disagreement.

Below, you'll find two of Peikoff's podcasts on this topic and one from Hsieh. I'd love to hear your thoughts. Which do you agree with? Why? Is there another position or major Objectivist out there who has a similar position on this?

Peikoff

"Is it proper for a doctor to perform a sex-change operation for a patient?"

"In a previous podcast you said that it is wrong to go against nature by undergoing a sex-change operation–that the metaphysically given is an absolute. But by this definition gender is not metaphysically given because we can now change it if we so chose."

Hsieh

"Restrooms for the Transgendered in Transition"

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *